Updated points system for What a Tanker and AI tanker

Moderators: Laffe, Vis Bellica

SteveC
Posts: 68
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2019 3:23 pm
Location: Bath, UK

Re: Updated points system for What a Tanker and AI tanker

Post by SteveC »

List of attributes omits to mention 'TD' - but been used to calculated other values in the list, so needs to be include in the tally. Found this after building an Excel spread sheet to calculate vehicles not listed and did a few check calcs against existing listed ones to confirm it was working OK.

There is an error in the German list - the Stug III F8 should also be listed as 'low profile' as its structurally no different to the earlier F version or the following G version. This makes it cost 27 pts.

gzavatwar
Posts: 1
Joined: Tue Mar 01, 2022 7:14 am

Re: Updated points system for What a Tanker and AI tanker

Post by gzavatwar »

Hi,

Thank you for this new point calculation system. It is very nice and a lot more balanced imho.

Btw, I found the following values to be different from the PDF file (considering the TD attribute is worth +1):

* StuG III F8 = 28 (and not 25 nor 27)
* Panzer VI Tiger I = 66 (and not 67)
* M10 Achilles II = 33 (and not 31)
* Churchill Mk III/IV = 33 (and not 35)
* Churchill Mk VI = 35 (and not 37)
* A34 Comet = 48 (and not 53)
* Churchill Mk VI = 55 (and not 56)
* KV-1E = 42 (and not 30, due to bad APV/SPV same as KV-1 in PDF)
* T-34/85 M1943 = 44 (and not 45)
* ISU 122 = 58 (and not 57)
* ISU 152 = 76 (and not 47)

What do you think?

Rgds,
Xavier

SteveC
Posts: 68
Joined: Wed Apr 24, 2019 3:23 pm
Location: Bath, UK

Re: Updated points system for What a Tanker and AI tanker

Post by SteveC »

Agree most of the values you have identified except:

KV 1E : Armour 9, strike 5, slow, heavy amour = 33 (It had additional armour welded on all round, so should be armour 9 and not be the same as the KV 1)

ISU 152: Armour 8, strike 12, slow, Iron Fist = 69


Steve

Post Reply