Artillery not being able to use infantry refuge
Moderators: Vis Bellica, Laffe, DCRBrown
Artillery not being able to use infantry refuge
Artillery is not able to use nearby infantry as a refuge to escape a charge in GDA. I belive I read somewhere the authors justification for this but can't find it, any help?? Thanks.
Re: Artillery not being able to use infantry refuge
M,
Can I answer your question with a question.
Outside Waterloo, how many examples throughout the 20 years of the Napoleonic Wars has this tactic been recorded, commented on or written in the tactical manuals of any nation?
I've not found any mention of this outside Waterloo, though of course I could be wrong or missed examples.
Secondly, the wording attributed to British units at Waterloo is often very different to the wording attributed to French units or Prussian units, by British authors and historians over the years. If we used words normally associated with the French in this instance, we have "the British artillery crews broke and fled before the French cavalry charge, retreating to the safety of nearby infantry squares". This sounds a little different to "taking refuge."
After such a "manoeuvre" the ability of officers to reorganise their men and then to return to the guns and recommence firing would be limited at best.
The same act could have happened in numerous other battles but this is simply described as "the enemy batteries were overrun".
DB
Can I answer your question with a question.
Outside Waterloo, how many examples throughout the 20 years of the Napoleonic Wars has this tactic been recorded, commented on or written in the tactical manuals of any nation?
I've not found any mention of this outside Waterloo, though of course I could be wrong or missed examples.
Secondly, the wording attributed to British units at Waterloo is often very different to the wording attributed to French units or Prussian units, by British authors and historians over the years. If we used words normally associated with the French in this instance, we have "the British artillery crews broke and fled before the French cavalry charge, retreating to the safety of nearby infantry squares". This sounds a little different to "taking refuge."
After such a "manoeuvre" the ability of officers to reorganise their men and then to return to the guns and recommence firing would be limited at best.
The same act could have happened in numerous other battles but this is simply described as "the enemy batteries were overrun".
DB
Re: Artillery not being able to use infantry refuge
Cheers, I believe that is the sort of answer I was after, and also perhaps commensurate with Wellingtons criticism of his artillery's performance at Waterloo in fact (too much of the artillery fled and did not return)?